TO RING OR TO STENT
Tracheal collapse is a progressive, chronic, debilitating disease occurring primarily in
middle-aged toy-breed dogs. Pomeranians, Poodles, Yorkshire Terriers, and Chihuahuas are
most commonly affected. The clinical signs of tracheal collapse are a chronic nonproductive
cough, exercise intolerance, and varying degrees of dyspnea. The cough often resembles a
“honking-sound.” Clinical signs are exacerbated by excitement or anxiety and may precede to
collapse and syncope.
The dorsal membrane and cartilage rings are both involved in the degenerative process.
The rings become hypoplastic or fibrodystrophic and cannot maintain the normal C-shaped
configuration. Affected tracheas lack glucosamine glycan chondroitin sulfate resulting in loss of
cartilage rigidity. The dorsal membrane is redundant and drawn into the cervical tracheal lumen
during inspiration and into the thoracic tracheal lumen during expiration. The disease often
progresses to involve the bronchi. The degree of collapse is classified from grade I (slight
collapse with mild membrane redundancy) to grade IV (total collapse with the dorsal membrane
lying on the tracheal ring).
Palpation of the cervical region often reveals a flaccid, flattened trachea and stimulates a
cough. The degree and severity of the collapse is best determined by radiography and
tracheoscopy. Radiographs of the sedated patient during both inspiration and expiration will help
to determine whether the collapse is in the cervical or thoracic trachea or both are involved.
Tracheoscopy often gives a more accurate picture of the disease than does radiography. Flexible
endoscopy provides the opportunity to evaluate the entire airway including laryngeal function,
trachea, and bronchi. The need is to evaluate the entire airway including the bronchi where
correction is not currently possible.
Medical management includes weight loss, cough suppressants, bronchial dilators, and
sedation as needed to control anxiety and excitement. Medical management can result in long
term resolution of clinical signs in many cases as long as other medical problems are
appropriately addressed. Some cases are refractory to medical care while others progress to a
point of requiring surgical treatment.
Numerous techniques have been described for surgical correction of collapsed trachea.
One of the first was dorsal membrane plication. This procedure results in significant reduction in
trachea diameter. External splinting has been used for many years. Surgical placement of
polypropylene C-shaped stents made from syringe barrels have been proven to be effective
especially in dogs less than 6 years old.
Modification of the external ring technique includes a polypropylene spiral which
attempts to provide a continuous support of the trachea. These rings and spirals are rather stiff
and must be drilled for placement of sutures. Another modification includes the use of a
polyvinylchloride ring made from intravenous drip chambers in place of the polypropylene rings
or spirals. The rings can be purchased in various sizes commercially (New Generation) and are
preferred over the home-made ones.
Tunnels are carefully dissected around the trachea preserving the tracheal blood supply
and the recurrent laryngeal nerves. The trachea is sutured in four locations to the ring using 4-0
polypropylene suture. The sutures pull the collapsed trachea outward to the ring relieving the
collapse. A ring is placed every centimeter (every 3rd-4th ring) along the cervical trachea.
Placing rings on the thoracic trachea is difficult. All of the external devices require some
interruption on trachea blood supply and dissection of the recurrent laryngeal nerve. This can
result in major morbidity and mortality. To overcome this later complication, some have
combined the rings with arytenoid lateralization. Over time the trachea tends to collapse between
the rings or at the proximal or distal ends of external rings. The collapse often proceeds to
involve the bronchi.
Permanently implanted internal stents have been used to support human tracheas
collapsed from malacia or cancer. These have recently been employed in cases of canine
collapsed trachea. The Palmaz ® stent was used but complications included pulmonary edema,
stent migration, stent collapse, obstruction with granulation and cough. Better results were
obtained from the use of Wallstent ®.
We began to use the Ultraflex ® stent (Boston Scientific) several years ago. We limited
the use to dogs with either grade III or IV collapse and were severely compromised by their
disease. Definitive diagnosis of collapsed trachea and the diameter and length of the collapse
was determined by radiography and endoscopy. Endoscopy appeared to be more accurate at
determining the severity of the collapse. The diameter of the collapsed trachea and the size of the
stent to be placed was determined by placing a cuffed endotracheal tube in the larynx and
applying positive pressure to the airway. The maximum tracheal diameter was then measured
from a lateral radiograph with the trachea under positive pressure of 20 mmHg. A 4 to 8 cm long
stent was chosen with the diameter equal to the maximum trachea size under positive pressure as
determined by radiographs and endoscopy.
The dogs were anesthetized with injectable anesthetic (propofol) with oxygen provided
through the endoscopy. The proximal and distal extent of the collapsed segment was determined
with endoscopy. The stent catheter was positioned and the self-expanding stent was deployed.
The positioning of the stent and dilation of the trachea was confirmed with endoscopy.
Anesthesia was discontinued and the dogs observed in the ICU overnight then discharged the
following day. Corticosteroid and antibiotics are administered for 14 days post-implant.
Stents can be placed in both cervical and thoracic trachea. The stents are available in
various lengths and diameters. Most dogs will require only one stent but some may require 2
placed end-to-end. Some stented patients do very well long term with only a slight cough.
However, others have developed some granulation tissue over the stent, and others have fractured
the stent resulting in re-collapse.
Stents have many advantages over rings. Some of these include: no chance of damage to
the segmented trachea blood supply or to the recurrent laryngeal nerve, can be placed quickly,
avoiding lengthy surgery, provides continuous support along the entire stented trachea, and
subsequent stents can be placed if additional collapse occurs.
The disadvantages are that the stent is very expensive, proper application requires both
endoscopy and fluoroscopy, chronic cough can occur if the stents are placed close to the cricoid,
granulation tissue can build up at the ends of the stents, and the stents can fracture resulting in
recurrent collapse. A possible “best” approach might be to place rings on the cervical trachea to
reduce expense and reserve stents for the thoracic trachea where rings are not feasible.
©2016 / CollapsingTrachea.Com
All graphics and information on these pages belong solely to YTNR.
Please don't copy or remove anything from these pages.